Problem with my xbox 360?

I'm having a problem with my xbox 360 with an extra controller being signed in (On the xbox itself, the first player and second player lights are signed in). I first had this problem on Netflix, I was watching Prison Break Season 2. My controller idled and turned off, the episode ended and I turned my controller back on to start a new show but I noticed the controller had the second part of the ring lit up. I accidentally left my xbox on all last night, so I turned on my controller and I had somehow been disconnected from xbox live and my controller was signed in as the second player. So I turned it off and restarted it. Now I'm finally in the first player spot, but my xbox still shows that there are two controllers turned on and registered to my xbox.



My brother and I only have 3 controllers and they're all right by me, with my controller being the only one that is actually on. Oh yeah, and everybody else is asleep so nobody could just be messing with me. Now, this probably isn't the best place to find answers for this (my questions in the past couple of months haven't been being answered), so I will also be posting this on the xbox forum.Problem with my xbox 360?
You could always try new batteries. If that doesn't work then I have no idea why that's happening.Problem with my xbox 360?
Sounds like the RF module that connect to the controllers is screwing up. If this happened after an update then you could ask Microsoft about it but worse comes to worse you would have to buy and install a new RF module. source #1 has good directions for doing so but as for buying one, they can be as cheap as $5. But before you do any of that test all your controllers and make sure its the Xbox and not just one of the controllers.